- 2006-2007 Chief Scott Summers
- 2005-2006 Chief Pat Duff
- 2004 - 2005 Chief Gregg Badalich
- 2003 - 2004 Chief Randy Wallace
- 2002 - 2003 Chief Pat Marks
- 2001 - 2002 Chief Paul Giesel
- 2000 - 2001 Chief Jeff Will
- 1999 - 2000 Chief Bob Mahaney
- 1998 - 1999 Chief Ray Herrick
- 1997 - 1998 Chief Todd Jones
- 1996 - 1997 Chief Jerry Ramsey
- 1995 - 1996 Chief Ray Herrick
- 1994 - 1995 Chief Paul Andrella
- 1993 - 1994 Chief Mike Grimes
- 1992 - 1993 Chief Don Suboticki
- 1991 - 1992 Chief Keith Gwyn
- 1990 - 1991 Chief John P. Markwood III
- 1989 - 1990 Chief Dan Atha
- 1988 - 1989 Chief Greg Rogers
- 1987 - 1988 Chief Bob Bernat
- 1986 - 1987 Chief Phil First
- 1985 - 1986 Chief Rob Dumke
- 1984 - 1985 Chief Larry Wagner
- 1983 - 1984 Chief Chuck Myers
- 1982 - 1983 Chief John Lyons
- 1981 - 1982 Chief Dan Stober
- 1980 - 1981 Chief Ray Hanley
- 1979 - 1980 Chief Larry Light
- 1978 - 1979 Chief Dave Blough
- 1977 - 1978 Chief John Bower
- 1976 - 1977 Chief Lee Park
- 1975 - 1976 Chief Mike Gmerek / Lee Park
- 1974 - 1975 Chief Don Ries
- 1973 - 1974 Chief Tom Anderson
- 1972 - 1973 Chief Joe Koehler
- 1971 - 1972 Chief George Bower
